Nepal's Constitutional Foundations between Revolution and Cold War (1950–60)
Keywords:
Nepal constitutional history, 1950s Nepal, decolonization, year 7 revolution, King Tribhuvan Shah, Rana regime, democratic political parties, 1951 Interim ConstitutionAbstract
The 1950s represent a foundational decade in Nepal's constitutional history. In the wake of decolonization in British India, the “year 7 revolution” (1950–51) grew out of the alliance between King Tribhuvan Shah and Nepal's democratic political parties created in India against the Rana autocratic regime in Kathmandu. Eventually the pro-democracy forces prevailed, and a crucial political transition began. Two constitutions were promulgated, the 1951 Interim Constitution and the 1959 Constitution. Both short lived and only partially implemented, these documents, however, laid the foundations of Nepal's constitutional edifice for years to come. Constitution building became a marker of sovereignty understood in terms of independence and an assertion of popular sovereignty. However, in the fraught Cold War context, the preoccupation with securing political stability by constitutional means that centered around the Shah monarchy prevailed, even at the expense of democracy. As such, the shift from a traditional notion of sovereignty from above to a modern concept of sovereignty from below remained incomplete. These aspirations, however, were not extinguished even by 30 years of royal autocracy under the Panchayat regime (1960–90) and lived on to this day to inform demands for constitutional reform, democratization, and inclusion. The present analysis is based on Nepali primary legal sources, archival material from the United Kingdom and United States National Archives, and the Ivor Jennings Private Papers.
References
1
Joshi, B.L. and Rose, L., Democratic Innovations in Nepal: A Case Study of Political Acculturation (Berkeley: University of California Press,1966, 2004 reprint), ixGoogle Scholar.
2
The Interim Government of Nepal Act, 2007 BS (1951 CE).
3
The Constitution of the Kingdom of Nepal, 2015 BS (1959 CE).
4
Malagodi, Mara, “The Locus of Sovereign Authority in Nepal,” in Unstable Constitutionalism: Law and Politics in South Asia, ed. Tushnet, Mark and Khosla, Madhav (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015), 45–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5
Loughlin, M., Foundations of Public Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), 285CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6
De, Rohit, “Theory and Practice of India's Dominion Status,” International Journal of Constitutional Law 17 (2019): 1213–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Malagodi, Mara, “Dominion Status and the Origins of Authoritarian Constitutionalism in Pakistan,” International Journal of Constitutional Law 17 (2019): 1235–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7
Abeyratne, Rehan, “Uncertain Sovereignty: Ceylon as a Dominion 1948–1972,” International Journal of Constitutional Law 17 (2019): 1258–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
8
Chene, Mary Des, “Is Nepal in South Asia? The Condition of Non-Postcoloniality,” Studies in Nepali History and Society 12 (2007): 218–19Google Scholar.
9
McMahon, R., The Cold War on the Periphery: The United States, India, and Pakistan (New York: Columbia University Press, 1996) 5–6Google Scholar.
10
In the 1950s, Nepal established diplomatic relations with the following countries: PRC (1955), USSR (1956), Japan (1956), Sri Lanka (1957), Egypt (1957), Federal Republic of Germany (1958), Austria (1959), Italy (1959), Serbia (1959), Switzerland (1959), and Poland (1959). https://mofa.gov.np/foreign-policy/diplomatic-relations/ (August 21, 2021).
11
Engerman, D.C., The Price of Aid. The Economic Cold War in India (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2018)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
12
Pigg, Stacey, “Inventing Social Categories through Place: Social Representations and Development in Nepal,” Comparative Studies in Society and History 34 (1992): 497CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13
A. Jalal, The State of Martial Rule: The Origins of Pakistan's Political Economy of Defence (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990).
14
J. Whelpton, A History of Nepal (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), 86.
15
Malagodi, “The Locus of Sovereign Authority in Nepal,” 45–85.
16
M. Malagodi, Constitutional Nationalism and Legal Exclusion–Equality, Identity Politics, and Democracy in Nepal, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013).
17
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 73–74.
18
Ibid., 83–84.
19
Goldstein, Melvyn C., “The United States, Tibet, and the Cold War,” Journal of Cold War Studies 8 (2006): 148CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
20
J.K. Knauss, Orphans of the Cold War. America and the Tibetan Struggle for Survival (New York: PublicAffairs, 1999), 44.
21
B. Khanal, Regeneration of Nepalese Law (Kathmandu: Bhrikuti Academic Publications, 2001), 34.
22
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 488.
23
Mara Malagodi, Luke McDonagh, and Thomas Poole “The Dominion Model of Transitional Constitutionalism,” International Journal of Constitutional Law 17 (2019): 1283–300.
24
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 488.
25
Whelpton, A History of Nepal, 89.
26
L. Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1971), 200.
27
Ibid.
28
Jennings/ICS/B13/1.2, Royal Proclamation, 7 Māgh 2010 BS (January 20, 1954).
29
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 208.
30
Gyawali, Bandana, “From Development to Bīkas: Nepal's Transition to Democracy and the Emergence of a Concept’ Studies in Nepali History and Society 21:1 (2019), 19Google Scholar.
31
Robertson, Thomas, ““Front Line of the Cold War”: The US and Point Four Development Programs in Cold War Nepal, 1950–1953” Studies in Nepali History and Society 21:1 (2019), 41–72Google Scholar.
32
Gyawali, “From Development to Bīkas”, 22.
33
Rose, Nepal – Strategy for Survival, 209.
34
United States Embassy, New Delhi to Department of State (DOS), October 14, 1955, Telegram, File 790C.5-MSP/10-1455, United States National Archives II, College Park, Maryland, United States (hereafter NARA II).
35
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, November 23, 1955, Telegram, File 790C.5-MSP/11-2355, NARA II.
36
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 210.
37
Whelpton, A History of Nepal, 91.
38
FO letter to Jennings, May 11, 1956, ICS 125/B/xiii/4, Jennings Private Papers, Institute of Commonwealth Studies, London, United Kingdom (hereafter ICS).
39
Jennings letter to FO, May 13, 1956, ICS 125/B/xiii/4.
40
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 189–90.
41
Hora Prasad Joshi, 1958. The Way to Political Stability–An Analysis, ICS 125/B/xiii/1.4.
42
SOA to SOA, July 30, 1956, Office Memorandum, File 790C.5-MSP/7-3056, NARA II.
43
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, August 31, 1956, Telegram, File 790C.5-MSP/8-3156, NARA II.
44
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 210–11.
45
DOS to United States Embassy, New Delhi, November 23, 1956, Instruction, File 790C.5-MSP/11-2256, NARA II.
46
Knauss, Orphans of the Cold War, 138.
47
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 213.
48
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, November 9, 1956, Foreign Service Dispatch, File 790C.34/11-956, NARA II.
49
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, March 8, 1957, Foreign Service Dispatch, File 790C.13/3-857, NARA II.
50
FO letter to Jennings, April 26, 1957, ICS 125/B/xiii/4.
51
British Ambassador to Nepal J.A. Scopes letter to FO, June 16, 1958, FO 371/135966.
52
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, June 4, 1957, Telegram, File 790C.5-MSP/6-457, NARA II.
53
United States Government, July 15, 1957, Office Memorandum “Fall of the Nepalese Ministry,” File 790C.13/7-1557, NARA II.
54
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, June 13, 1957, Foreign Service Dispatch, File 790C.5-MSP/6-1357, NARA II.
55
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 216.
56
United States Embassy, New Delhi to DOS, July 24, 1957, Telegram, File 790C.13/7-2457, NARA II.
57
Joshi 1958, The Way to Political Stability–An Analysis, 17–19, ICS 125/B/xiii/1/iv.
58
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 199.
59
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 217.
60
FO letter to Jennings, December 13, 1957, ICS 125/B/xiii/4.
61
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 210.
62
Jennings letter to FO, January 19, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/4.
63
Jennings letter to FO, April 27, 1958, FO371/135966.
64
FO to British Embassy, Kathmandu, May 12, 1958, FO371/135966.
65
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 210.
66
Ibid., 272.
67
B.P. Koirala, Atmabrittanta–Late Life Recollections, (Kathmandu: Himal Books, 2001), 182.
68
Jennings Explanatory Memorandum, April 21, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/2/iv.
69
Ibid.
70
Jennings Confidential Notes on Nepal for FO, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/5/ii.
71
Jennings letter to FO, April 27, 1958, FO371/135966.
72
British Ambassador to Nepal J.A. Scopes letter to FO, June 16, 1958, FO 371/135966.
73
Jennings Third Draft, April 20, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/2/iv.
74
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 218.
75
DOS, November 21, 1958, Memorandum of Conversation “Nepalese Desire for Assistance by the United States,” File 790C.5/11-2158, NARA II.
76
Jennings Confidential Notes on Nepal, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/5/i.
77
Joshi and Rose, Democratic Innovations in Nepal, 285.
78
Malagodi, Mara, “Constitution-Drafting as Cold war Realpolitik: Sir Ivor Jennings and Nepal's 1959 Constitution,” in Constitution-Making in Asia, ed. Kumarasingham, Harshan (London: Routledge, 2016), 167Google Scholar.
79
Ibid. 168–69.
80
Jennings Confidential Notes on Nepal, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/5/i. Malagodi, Mara, “Dominion Status and the Origins of Authoritarian Constitutionalism in Pakistan,” International Journal of Constitutional Law 17 (2019): 1235–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
81
Whelpton, A History of Nepal, 93.
82
Jennings Confidential Notes on Nepal for FO, 1958, ICS 125/B/xiii/5/ii.
83
Zavos, John, “Defending Hindu Tradition: Sanatana Dharma as a Symbol of Orthodoxy in Colonial India,” Religion 31 (2001): 109–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
84
Koirala, Atmabrittanta, 182–83.
85
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 220.
86
Ibid. 220–21.
87
Whelpton, A History of Nepal, 95.
88
Ibid., 96.
89
Rose, Nepal–Strategy for Survival, 221–22.
90
United States Embassy, Kathmandu to DOS, September 9, 1959, incoming Airgram, File 790C.5/9-959, NARA II.
91
United States Embassy, Kathmandu to DOS, September 23, 1959, Embassy Telegram N.20, File 790C.21/9-2359, NARA II.
92
DOS to United States Embassy, Kathmandu, November 25, 1959, Outgoing Airgram, File 790C.11/12-459, NARA II.
93
Afsah, Ebrahim, “Afghanistan: An Aborted Beginning,” in Constitutional Foundings in South Asia, eds. Kevin Y.L. Tan and Ridwanul Hoque (London: Hart Publishing, 2021), 231–61Google Scholar.
